Monday 14 July 2008

UK: Companies House - appeals against late filing penalties

The Companies House adjudicator, Dame Elizabeth Neville DBE QPM, has published her first report (for the period 1 August 2007 - 31 March 2008). One of the roles of the adjudicator is to hear appeals against late filing penalties imposed by Companies House (and upheld, internally, by the Senior Appeals Manager). In this regard, the following extracts from Dame Elizabeth's report are of interest (paras. 2.8 and 2.16):

There were seven cases where directors experienced some serious problem which delayed the submission of the accounts. These included bereavement, and illness. However, in none of these cases was the individual a sole director. All directors have equal responsibility to ensure that accounts are submitted on time. Where one director has primary responsibility for submitting accounts and some catastrophe overwhelms him or her, other directors must be prepared to step into the breach. It is apparent that some directors are that in name only, and are either unable or unwilling to act when it becomes necessary. 

I upheld one appeal. In this case, property developers had been the directors of a property management company. They had managed it so badly that Companies House had dissolved it. The residents of the property development were obliged to apply for the company to be reinstated because of restrictive covenants on their properties, incurring the late filing penalties of the previous directors. Whilst supporting the policy of Companies House that outstanding late filing penalties must stand when a dissolved company is reinstated, notwithstanding a change of directors, I considered the circumstances of this case to be exceptional as the residents had no choice but to reinstate the company, had been ill treated by the property developer, and had already incurred considerable expense".

Notes: 

[1] The directors' duty to file accounts with the registrar of companies is imposed by Section 441 of the Companies Act (2006). Note also Part 35 - "The Registrar of Companies" - of the Act. 

[2] In July 2008, Companies House published revised guidance on late filing penalty appeals: see here

[3] All limited companies in England, Wales and Scotland are registered at Companies House, an executive agency of the Department for Business, Enterprise and Regulatory Reform. There are over 2,000,000 registered companies. There is a Registrar for England and Wales and another for Scotland. For information about incorporating a company, see here

No comments: